← Back to insights
Real estate · Tax planning20 November 2026

Selling German Real Estate or Holding? Deal Check, Foreign Structures and Tax Traps 2026

Should you be selling German real estate while you still can? The thesis is popular, and it is often garnished with questionable offers and even more questionable tax tips. We recalculate a typical multi-family offer from the Ruhr area, examine the popular idea of a ‘tax-optimised’ investment via a foreign holding and assess the arguments against German bricks and mortar with current data.

By Philipp Steiner
Selling German real estate or holding – period multi-family building in a large German city
Key takeaways
  • ✛The deal does not add up: 6.1% gross yield, 90% debt financing at 4% plus 2% repayment – after operating costs, cash flow is negative. A 50/50 profit split for property management is not market practice when the investor provides 100% of capital and risk.
  • ✛A foreign holding is no tax trick: profit shares from a typical silent partnership or profit-participating loan are subject to 26.375% German withholding tax. Foreign corporations can reclaim two-fifths – but only with genuine substance (Sec. 50d(3) Income Tax Act).
  • ✛Atypical silent partnership = permanent establishment: anyone sharing in the exit proceeds generally becomes a co-entrepreneur and is taxable in Germany on their share.
  • ✛The market is not frozen: according to vdp, multi-family prices rose 0.5% and new-lease rents 3.5% year on year in Q3 2026. Sales do happen – but only at realistic prices.
  • ✛Regulation eased, not tightened: the Building Modernisation Act abolished the 65% rule on 29 July 2026. The 10-year speculation period remains unchanged.
  • ✛Abroad is not automatically tax-free: since 2026 Argentina only exempts long-term residential lettings by individuals from income tax – not holiday or luxury lettings.

The offer: 50% of profits for property management

Offers like the following currently reach wealthy investors frequently. A multi-family house in Essen-Rüttenscheid with 9 units and 785 m² of living space is to be bought for EUR 1,769,000 plus EUR 204,700 in transaction costs. Annual rent is EUR 108,500.

Who does what in the offer
PartyContributionShare
InvestorAll equity, all transaction costs, full liability to the bank, first-loss risk50% of cash flow and appreciation
PromoterProperty management and local support (market value about EUR 250–300 per month)50% of cash flow and appreciation

A profit share for the local partner is not wrong per se. In joint ventures, sponsors often receive a ‘promote’ of 10 to 30% – but only after the investor has achieved a minimum return, and usually with their own capital at stake. 50% without capital and without sharing losses is not normal market practice.

The deal recalculated

The criticism of the ‘back-of-the-envelope maths’ is justified. With realistic assumptions, the picture looks like this:

Selling or buying German real estate – multi-family deal check: rental income, operating costs, debt service and negative cash flow
From rental income to cash flow: nothing is left after debt service
Multi-family house Essen-Rüttenscheid – year 1
ItemEUR per yearAssumption
Annual net rent108,500Gross yield 6.1% on purchase price
Management– 3,240EUR 30 per unit and month
Maintenance– 10,990EUR 14 per m² of living space
Vacancy and bad debt– 2,1702% of rent
Net operating income (NOI)92,1004.7% on total investment
Debt service– 96,000EUR 1.6 million loan, 4% interest, 2% repayment
Cash flow before tax– 3,900Debt service coverage 0.96

Three points stand out:

  • ✛Hardly bankable: the loan equals about 90% of the purchase price. For income properties, banks usually require debt service coverage (DSCR) of at least 1.1 to 1.2. At 0.96 the investor would have to contribute more than the roughly EUR 374,000 of equity mentioned.
  • ✛Not everything goes to the tax office: of the EUR 204,700 in costs, about EUR 115,000 is real estate transfer tax (North Rhine-Westphalia: 6.5%). The rest is notary, land registry and agent fees.
  • ✛Wrong term: there is no such thing as ‘EBITDA after bank debt service’. Property valuation works with net operating income (NOI), debt service coverage and cash-on-cash return.

The property is not worthless, though: repayments build up about EUR 384,000 of equity over 10 years, and a price of about EUR 2,250 per m² is moderate for Rüttenscheid. But if appreciation is split 50/50, the investor loses out: at 2% annual growth, about EUR 194,000 would go to the property manager after 10 years – for a service that costs about EUR 30,000 on the market.

The foreign holding as a ‘tax trick’: what really applies

Particularly delicate is the suggestion to invest in the German property company as a silent partner or through a profit-participating loan via a holding in Panama, the UAE or a US LLC. The criticism of this is essentially correct but needs refining on some points.

Typical silent partnership and profit-participating loan

  • ✛Withholding tax: profit shares are investment income under Sec. 20(1) No. 4 Income Tax Act. The company must withhold 25% withholding tax plus solidarity surcharge, 26.375% in total (Sec. 43(1) No. 3). For the foreign recipient this is German-source income under Sec. 49(1) No. 5.
  • ✛No double taxation at company level: contrary to frequent claims, profit shares are deductible business expenses of the company and reduce its profit. For trade tax a portion is added back; for pure asset management with the extended deduction this usually does not matter.
  • ✛Not 0% refund: under Sec. 44a(9), foreign corporations get two-fifths of the withholding tax refunded, reducing the burden to 15.825%. However, the holding must pass the anti-abuse rule of Sec. 50d(3). A letterbox company without staff and its own business activity fails.
  • ✛Treaties hardly help: there is no double tax treaty with Panama, and the treaty with the UAE expired at the end of 2021. The treaty with the US allows Germany to tax income of silent partners and from profit-participating loans under German law. A transparent US LLC also has no treaty protection of its own.

Atypical silent partnership

If the silent partner also shares in hidden reserves and exit proceeds, they are generally a co-entrepreneur. The company and the atypical silent partner then form a partnership for tax purposes. If it is commercial, it gives the foreign partner a permanent establishment in Germany. Their profit share is taxed here with corporate or income tax and possibly trade tax, including a separate profit determination. The statement ‘immediate permanent establishment’ is therefore correct in principle.

Important

Since 2019, the later sale of shares in a German property company has also been taxable in Germany for foreigners if its assets consist mainly of German real estate (Sec. 49(1) No. 2(e)). The foreign holding therefore does not move the tax out of Germany.

Anyone using a foreign company for international business should know the risks of a permanent establishment and permanent representative. For German real estate it is almost never the right vehicle. Our article on the US-German Friendship Treaty explains why the treaty does not change this either.

Selling German real estate: the arguments fact-checked

The call for selling German real estate and never buying again rests on a series of arguments. Some are accurate, others exaggerated:

Arguments against German bricks and mortar – assessment as of November 2026
ArgumentAssessment
‘Hardly sellable at market value any more’Exaggerated. vdp Q3 2026: multi-family prices +0.5%, new-lease rents +3.5% year on year. CBRE: residential investment Q1–Q3 2026 about EUR 5.9 billion, only 4% below the previous year. Sales take longer and need realistic prices
Situs principle: the state reaches it directlyAccurate. Real estate is location-bound; property tax and transfer tax attach to the location. No structure moves the building
Property tax explosionPartly. The new property tax has applied since 2025 and residential burdens rose in many cities. It can, however, be passed on to tenants
Cold expropriation through heating law and the EU buildings directiveOutdated. The Building Modernisation Act abolished the 65% rule on 29 July 2026; working heating systems may keep running. The EU directive sets national average targets for residential buildings, not a renovation duty per house
Tenancy lawAccurate. Rent brake extended to the end of 2029, rent increase caps, preservation areas. Rental upside is often only partly achievable
Abolition of the speculation periodUncertain but not adopted. A Green party bill from June 2026 exists; the coalition agreement contains nothing; a similar motion failed in 2025
Sec. 2 Foreign Tax Act after emigrationAccurate. German property worth over EUR 154,000 counts as a substantial domestic interest. Anyone moving to a low-tax country remains subject to extended limited tax liability for up to 10 years
Capital levy, compulsory mortgagesSpeculative. No bill exists. More in our capital levy fact check
‘Globally 8–12%, liquid and tax-free’Misleading. Return depends on risk, tax freedom on residence. For German residents, foreign income is taxable

The conclusion lies in between: German existing properties are no longer a sure thing in 2026. With interest rates around 4%, many properties with 5 to 6% gross yield no longer pay for themselves. But a blanket sell recommendation is just as unjustified as a blanket buy recommendation.

Sell, hold or reallocate? A decision guide

Whether selling German real estate makes sense for you depends less on headlines than on your personal situation:

Typical situations and options
SituationRather sellRather hold
Speculation period10 years have passed, gain can be realised tax-freePeriod still running, a sale would be taxable
Cash flowPermanently negative, large renovation backlogPositive, rents below market with upside
FinancingFixed rate ends soon, refinancing much more expensiveLow fixed rate runs for years
Planned emigrationMove to a low-tax country, Sec. 2 AStG riskStaying in Germany or moving to a treaty country with normal taxation
Holding structurePrivate assets, concentration risk in one cityAsset-management company with profit retention

Anyone planning to emigrate should plan the sequence: selling before or after moving, exit taxation on company shares (Sec. 6 AStG) and the consequences of extended limited tax liability. Our article on German exit taxation and the guide to emigrating from Germany help with this. On whether a company makes sense as a holding structure, read taxes for a GmbH.

Real estate abroad: what ‘tax-free’ really means

Argentina is often cited as the alternative: tax-free rents, deregulated tenancy law, demand in US dollars. Part of this is true:

  • ✛Tenancy law: with Decree 70/2023 the Milei government repealed the restrictive rental law. Lease term, currency and indexation are freely negotiable.
  • ✛Tax exemption: since January 2026, rental income of individuals has been exempt from Argentine income tax if the home serves as the tenant’s only, permanent family residence (Decree 406/2026). Companies and trust structures are excluded. Holiday and short-term lettings to international guests are not covered.
  • ✛Residence country counts: German residents must also declare Argentine rental income in Germany. Depending on the treaty, it is exempt but increases the tax rate on other income.

A foreign property can therefore only be ‘100% tax-free’ in combination with the right residence. Currency, legal and liquidity risks come on top. Background on Argentina is in our article on Argentina citizenship by investment; the principle of taxing only domestic income is explained in the article on territorial taxation.

Considering selling or reallocating German real estate – and want to know the tax consequences first?

Tax assessment →

Conclusion: calculate, don’t believe

The Essen example shows two mistakes that often go together: a deal that does not pay for itself at realistic costs, and a foreign structure that does more tax harm than good. A holding in Panama, the UAE or the US does not make German rental income tax-free.

The thesis that you should be selling German real estate is justified as a wake-up call but wrong as a blanket judgement. What matters are the speculation period, cash flow, financing and your residence planning. Anyone who assesses these factors soberly can sell, hold or diversify internationally in a targeted way. Our tax optimisation service supports you.

Frequently asked questions

Should I sell my German property now?

Not as a rule. A sale makes sense mainly if the 10-year speculation period has expired, cash flow is permanently negative or a move to a low-tax country is planned. If the period or cheap financing is still running, holding may be better.

Has the German property market collapsed in 2026?

No. According to vdp, multi-family prices rose 0.5% and new-lease rents 3.5% year on year in Q3 2026. Sales, however, need realistic prices and more time.

What tax applies to profit shares of a foreign silent partner?

For a typical silent partnership or profit-participating loan, the German company withholds 26.375% tax. Foreign corporations can reclaim two-fifths if they meet the substance requirements of Sec. 50d(3) Income Tax Act.

Will the speculation period for real estate be abolished?

Not as of November 2026. A Green party bill from June 2026 exists, but the coalition agreement provides for no abolition. A similar motion was rejected in 2025.

Do I have to replace my heating because of the heating law?

No. The Building Modernisation Act abolished the 65% rule on 29 July 2026. Existing oil and gas heating may keep running, but only with climate-neutral fuels from 2045.

Is rental income in Argentina tax-free?

Since 2026 for individuals, if the home serves as the tenant’s only, permanent family residence. Holiday and short-term lettings are not covered, and German residents must also declare the income in Germany.

Reorganise your property portfolio

We review selling, holding or reallocating with you – including the speculation period, holding structure, emigration planning and international diversification.

This article is a general analysis and does not replace individual tax or legal advice. Regulations change; the information reflects the status at the date of publication.

SWICOR.SWISS CORPORATE SOLUTIONS
Bank Account
All locations at a glance →
Bank account in SwitzerlandBank account in GeorgiaBank account in the USABank account in ArmeniaBank account in KazakhstanBank account in KyrgyzstanBank account in CambodiaBank account in Cape VerdeBank account in the Dominican Rep.Bank account in Uzbekistan
Company Formation
All jurisdictions at a glance →
Company formation in SwitzerlandCompany formation in GeorgiaCompany formation in the USACompany formation in EnglandCompany formation in NevisCompany formation in MaltaCompany formation in DubaiCompany formation in Hong KongCompany formation in SingaporeCompany formation in PanamaCompany formation in EstoniaCompany formation in CyprusCompany formation in Cambodia
Services
All services at a glance →
Tax OptimisationResidency AbroadSecond CitizenshipRegistered AddressBoard & DirectorAccounting & TaxDocuments & LegalisationBack-Office Packages
About
CompanyOur TeamPartners & Trust
Insights
Blog & InsightsKnowledge Hub
Contact
Book Consultation →

Share with