US-German Friendship Treaty: What It Really Does for a US LLC – and What It Does Not
The 1954 US-German Friendship Treaty is often sold as a ‘shield’ against the German state or a future capital levy – usually bundled with a US LLC holding German real estate. The treaty is law in force and genuinely important for US companies in Germany. But it offers no absolute protection against expropriation, taxes or wealth levies. We show what the treaty says, where its limits lie and why anonymity does not work in Germany.

- ✛Law in force: signed on 29 October 1954, promulgated in Germany in the Federal Law Gazette 1956 II No. 12, p. 487, in force since 14 July 1956. The treaty still applies today.
- ✛No ban on expropriation: Article V(4) permits expropriation for the public benefit, under due process of law and against compensation equivalent to the property taken.
- ✛Taxes remain: Article XI only requires equal treatment in taxation. A general wealth levy affecting Germans and US companies alike does not breach the treaty.
- ✛Limited legal protection: in Germany the treaty ranks as an ordinary federal statute. Disputes over its interpretation can only be brought by the two states, not by the individual LLC owner.
- ✛No anonymity: if a US LLC acquires German real estate, it must be entered in the transparency register. Without registration the notary may not notarise. Cash payment is prohibited.
- ✛Real benefit: the treaty secures the legal capacity and land-register capacity of US companies in Germany. That is its practical core.
US-German Friendship Treaty: what it is about
The ‘Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation between the United States of America and the Federal Republic of Germany’ was signed in Washington on 29 October 1954. The Bundestag approved it by law of 7 May 1956 (Federal Law Gazette 1956 II No. 12, p. 487). After ratifications were exchanged in Bonn, the treaty entered into force on 14 July 1956.
In 29 articles it governs the legal position of nationals and companies of each country in the other: entry, establishment, access to courts, property, taxation, payments and trade. The treaty initially ran for ten years and has continued indefinitely since. Either party may terminate it with one year’s notice (Article XXIX).
Its greatest practical importance today lies in Article XXV(5). Under it, companies formed under the laws of one party are deemed companies of that party in the other, and their legal status is recognised. This is why a US LLC has legal capacity and can sue and be sued in Germany – even when managed from Germany (Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 29 January 2003, VIII ZR 155/02). The Court applied this approach again to Delaware entities in its decision of 7 October 2026 (II ZB 18/24).
What Article V really says
Article V is the property protection clause that marketing for US LLC structures relies on. It has five paragraphs:
| Paragraph | Content |
|---|---|
| Para. 1 | Property of nationals and companies of the other party receives ‘the most constant protection and security’ |
| Para. 2 | Business premises may not be entered without just cause and may only be searched according to law |
| Para. 3 | No unreasonable or discriminatory measures against enterprises and interests of foreigners |
| Para. 4 | Expropriation only for the public benefit, in accordance with due process of law and against just compensation |
| Para. 5 | National and most-favoured-nation treatment for paras. 2 and 4, including nationalisation or placing under public control |
Compensation under para. 4 must represent the equivalent of the property taken, be in an effectively realisable form and be paid without needless delay. In practice this corresponds to market value.

The treaty speaks of property being ‘taken’. It contains no express wording on ‘measures having equivalent effect’ of the kind found in modern investment treaties. Whether indirect interference is covered is a matter of interpretation.
Expropriation is allowed – under three conditions
The treaty does not prohibit expropriation. It ties it to three conditions that German law broadly recognises anyway:
- 1Public interest: the expropriation must serve the public benefit.
- 2Due process: it must take place in a proper legal procedure (‘due process of law’).
- 3Just compensation: it must be compensated promptly, in a realisable form and at equivalent value.
How much extra protection does this add compared with the German Basic Law? A comparison:
| Criterion | Art. V(4) Friendship Treaty | Art. 14(3) Basic Law |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Public benefit | Public good |
| Procedure | Due process of law | Only by or pursuant to a law |
| Amount of compensation | Equivalent of the property | Fair balance between the public and those affected – may be below market value |
| Who is protected? | US nationals and US companies | Every owner |
| Enforcement | State against state (Article XXVII) | Before German courts, up to the Federal Constitutional Court |
The real added value therefore lies in one point: the treaty requires compensation at full equivalent value, whereas the Basic Law allows a balancing of interests. That is relevant, but it is not a ‘shield’. Expropriation remains possible; it only becomes more expensive.
Why the treaty does not override taxes and wealth levies
The core of many marketing promises is that a future capital levy would be an expropriation that a US LLC prevents. This does not hold for several reasons:
- ✛Taxes are not expropriation: the 1952 equalisation of burdens (Lastenausgleich) was a wealth levy, i.e. a tax. The Basic Law expressly provides for ‘one-off wealth levies’ (Art. 106(1) No. 5). Under general international law, a general, non-discriminatory tax is not an expropriation.
- ✛Article XI deals with taxes separately: US nationals and companies may not be taxed more heavily than Germans in the same situation. Equal levies are permitted. The treaty requires equal treatment, not tax exemption.
- ✛The owner remains taxable: anyone resident in Germany is taxed on worldwide wealth – including shares in a US LLC. A levy would typically be imposed on the shareholder, not just on the property.
- ✛Treaty override is permitted: in Germany the treaty ranks as an ordinary federal statute. In 2015 the Federal Constitutional Court ruled that a later statute may displace an international treaty domestically (2 BvL 1/12).
- ✛No right of action for investors: disputes over interpretation and application can only be brought by the two states, through negotiation, arbitration or before the International Court of Justice (Article XXVII). There is no investor-state arbitration as in modern treaties.
In addition: if the LLC is owned by German nationals living in Germany, it is doubtful whether the US would intervene diplomatically on their behalf. And whether a pure letterbox LLC enjoys treaty protection at all was left open by the Federal Court of Justice. In 2004, however, it considered even minor business activity in the US sufficient, such as a custody account with a US broker (judgment of 5 July 2004, II ZR 389/02).
How concrete is a capital levy in 2026?
As of November 2026 there is no government bill for a wealth levy. In March 2026 the Bundestag debated motions to reintroduce the wealth tax and referred them to the finance committee. The coalition agreement contains no wealth tax. Trade unions, by contrast, continue to call for a one-off wealth levy. Our capital levy and US LLC fact check explains the background and the tax consequences of holding real estate through an LLC.
No anonymity: transparency register, notary and anti-money laundering act
The second promise is anonymity: if the property belongs to a US LLC, nobody knows who is behind it. In Germany this is not true.
| Duty | What applies |
|---|---|
| Transparency register (Sec. 20 AML Act) | Foreign companies acquiring German real estate (including via share deal) must report their beneficial owners |
| Existing holdings (since 2023) | Since 1 January 2023 also for companies already holding real estate. The deadline for existing cases was 30 June 2023 |
| Notary | Without entry in the German or an EU transparency register and coherent documentation of the ownership and control structure, notarisation is prohibited |
| Identification | The notary identifies the parties and the beneficial owners and may not rely on the register alone |
| Cash ban (Sec. 16a AML Act) | Since 1 April 2023 the purchase price may not be paid in cash, crypto assets, gold or precious metals |
| Fines | Up to EUR 150,000 for first offences, up to EUR 1 million for serious or repeated offences, with publication |
| Tax office | Real estate transfer tax, limited tax liability of the LLC on rental income, the owner’s reporting duty under Sec. 138 Fiscal Code |
Since the European Court of Justice ruling of 22 November 2022, the transparency register is no longer open to everyone. Authorities, notaries, banks and persons with a legitimate interest, however, still see the data. Nor does the exemption of US companies from FinCEN reporting since March 2025 change anything: the German duties attach to the German property, not to US law.
Discretion towards neighbours, tenants or the public can partly be achieved with an LLC. Towards the state, the notary and the bank, the beneficial owner is always known. Read more on the line between legal privacy and concealment in our article on the EU asset register.
What a US LLC actually achieves in Germany
Without the shield rhetoric, solid advantages remain that follow directly from the US-German Friendship Treaty:
- ✛Legal and land-register capacity: the LLC can conclude contracts in Germany, sue and be registered as owner in the land register.
- ✛Limited liability: the company’s creditors generally cannot reach the members’ private assets.
- ✛Flexible succession: shares can be governed and transferred through the operating agreement without re-registering the property itself. Real estate transfer tax and gift tax must still be checked.
- ✛Equal treatment: Germany may not treat US companies worse than German ones, either in taxation or in property protection.
For tax purposes, the LLC is not automatic. German tax offices classify it as a corporation or partnership by comparing legal types. Corporate, income, real estate transfer and gift tax depend on this. On top come US duties such as Form 5472 and the risk that the LLC, if managed from Germany, creates a permanent establishment or permanent representative here. Our article on US corporation, LLC and LP covers choosing the right legal form.
Checklist: when a US LLC makes sense for German real estate
- 1Define the goal: is it about liability, succession or discretion? For ‘protection from the state’ the LLC is the wrong tool.
- 2Secure the tax classification: compare legal types before contributing property, and if in doubt obtain a binding ruling.
- 3Transparency register before the notary appointment: prepare the entry and structure documentation, otherwise the notarisation will fail.
- 4Structure financing properly: purchase price by bank transfer, source of funds documented.
- 5Do not forget the US side: registered agent, annual fees in the state of formation, Form 5472 and tax returns where required.
- 6Plan real asset protection: it comes from diversification across countries, banks and asset classes – and where appropriate from a change of residence. More in our guide to emigrating from Germany.
Considering a US LLC for your property or business and want to know what it really achieves?
US company formation →Conclusion: a valuable treaty, but no shield
The US-German Friendship Treaty is not a myth. Since 1956 it has secured the recognition of American companies in Germany and requires compensation at full equivalent value in case of expropriation. But it does not prohibit expropriation, does not protect against taxes or a general wealth levy and gives the individual LLC owner no right of action at international level.
Anonymity fails in Germany because of the anti-money laundering act, the transparency register and notaries’ duty to verify. Anyone using a US LLC should do so for liability, succession and international reach – not for promises the law does not keep. Our tax optimisation service is available to assess your situation. Our article on the US tax haven shows how the US ranks internationally as a wealth centre.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Friendship Treaty between the US and Germany still in force?
Yes. The treaty of 29 October 1954 has been in force since 14 July 1956 and has not been terminated. Either party may terminate it with one year’s notice.
Where can I find the original text of the treaty?
In the Federal Law Gazette 1956 Part II No. 12 from page 487 (law of 7 May 1956). All articles, including Article V on property protection, are printed there.
Does the Friendship Treaty prohibit expropriation?
No. Article V(4) permits expropriation for the public benefit, under due process of law and against prompt compensation equivalent to the property taken.
Does a US LLC protect against a capital levy?
Not reliably. A wealth levy is a tax, and Article XI only requires equal treatment in taxation. Moreover, a levy would typically be imposed on the shareholder resident in Germany.
Can a US LLC buy German real estate anonymously?
No. It must report its beneficial owners to the transparency register, otherwise the notary may not notarise. Cash payments for real estate have been prohibited since April 2023.
Can I as an LLC owner rely on the treaty directly?
Before German courts, yes, to the extent the treaty is directly applicable, for example regarding recognition of the company. There is no international right of action: disputes over the treaty are conducted only by the two states.
Use a US LLC realistically
We assess whether a US company makes sense for your property or business – from a tax and corporate law perspective and with a view to transparency and reporting duties in Germany and the US.
This article is a general analysis and does not replace individual tax or legal advice. Regulations change; the information reflects the status at the date of publication.